Vinny's Pizzeria Menu

Welcome to Vinny's Pizzeria, the hidden gem of Herkimer, New York. This charming pizzeria is renowned for its exceptional menu that elevates traditional Italian cuisine to glorious heights.

• Sicilian Pizza: Indulge in the delight of a perfectly crafted Sicilian pizza, praised by first-time visitors like Jennifer Conklin for its authentic flavor and irresistible crust.
• Subs and Calzones: Dive into hearty offerings such as the Large Meatball Sub, featuring five flavorful meatballs that have charmed locals like Marcus Harper-Munford and Maximum Carnage.
• Abundant Flavor: Deborah Bohn highlights the generous portions of mushrooms, showcasing the pizzeria’s commitment to quality ingredients and memorable dining experiences.

Whether you're stopping by for a slice, a savory sub, or something a little different, Vinny’s is the place to satisfy those cravings. The welcoming ambiance and generous space between tables make it a perfect spot for friends and family.